Hello dear
Welcome To Sutters Mill
Nestled in Suffern, NY, Sutters Mill offers a unique dining experience that blends comfort with culinary excellence. Renowned for its casual yet vibrant atmosphere, the restaurant is a haven for food lovers, featuring an impressive menu ranging from hearty chicken clubs to exquisite fish tacos. Patrons rave about the freshly cooked meals, including perfectly crispy wings and delicious steak. The ice-cold draft beer adds to the charm, making it the perfect spot to unwind after a long day. Under new management, Sutters Mill embraces a warm community spirit, inviting everyone to revisit and savor the delightful offerings.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Red
$7.28Chocolate Milk
$3.12Grilled Cheese
$8.32
BLT
$9.36Vodka Martini
$13.00Martini
$13.00
Bloody Mary
$$10.40White Russian
$$10.40Margarita
$$10.40 About
Sutters Mill
Welcome to Sutters Mill: A Culinary Oasis in Suffern, NY
Located at 214 NY59 in Suffern, NY, Sutters Mill offers a delightful dining experience that has garnered rave reviews from locals and visitors alike. This cozy eatery captures the essence of comfort and flavor, making it a go-to spot for everyone from families to professionals grabbing a well-deserved meal after a long day.
Atmosphere and Vibe
Sutters Mill boasts a relaxed, casual ambiance that sets the stage for a memorable meal. The atmosphere is often described as welcoming and not overcrowded, allowing guests to enjoy their dining experience fully. With friendly staff and attentive service, it feels like a home away from home.
Menu Highlights
The menu at Sutters Mill is a testament to the culinary creativity of its kitchen. Offerings range from hearty burgers to refreshing fish tacos, all prepared with quality ingredients:
- Chicken Club: A colossal sandwich that’s sure to satisfy even the heartiest of appetites.
- Fish Tacos: A delicious combination of cod and shrimp that pays homage to classic coastal flavors.
- Buffalo Wings: A beloved item that has retained its popularity with guests returning for a taste of nostalgia.
- N.Y. Fish Sandwich: Praised for its amazing flavors, this dish has been described as a highlight of the menu.
Drinks to Complement Your Meal
What pairs better with great food than equally fantastic drinks? Sutters Mill offers a variety of wines and spirits, including:
- Wine by the Glass: Choices include Sterling Merlot and Pinot Noir, priced affordably between $7.28 and $10.40.
- Tequila Selection: Sip on top-shelf brands like Patron and Casamigos, adding a touch of luxury to your dining experience.
Customer Experiences
Guests have expressed their delight with Sutters Mill, praising the culinary magic they encounter:
- Aurora C noted the relaxing atmosphere and the delicious salmon.
- Jeff Cifichiello reminisced about family dinners at this old-time favorite, indicating that Sutters Mill has truly returned to form.
- Debby "Brew" Sherr appreciated the frosty cold beers and the appealing decor, showing that small touches matter.
Final Thoughts
With its blend of scrumptious offerings and a warm, inviting atmosphere, Sutters Mill stands out as a culinary treasure in Suffern. Whether you are seeking a quick bite or a place to unwind with friends over a well-crafted meal, this restaurant has something for everyone. So, gather your loved ones and experience the delightful dishes that Sutters Mill has to offer. You won’t be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Relaxing not crowded great atmosphere Their salmon is delicious as are those sweet potato fries! ”
“ The chicken club was colossal!! The burger with Swiss was just delicious n juicy. The pickles r good 2. The coffee's not bad....didn't like the Buffalo wings. I asked 4 them 2 make them well done n boy did they! Lol, I did ask 4 grilled onions on my burger n I must say the onions where grilled nicely! The food was on point. Did I mention how big the chicken club is lol go enjoy! ”
“ This is an surreal oasis of culinary magic! I walked in exhausted after a long day of work as a hospital nurse. I ordered a draft beer and wow the glass was ice cold, the beer was ice cold with perfect carbonation(very rare to find). I ordered wings next and they came out fast, big, hot and crisp, just perfect. Next I ordered the NY fish sandwich and holy s*** it was hands down amazing. It was like I was in heaven and ordered the best fish sandwich in all the clouds. The staff were uplifting and down to earth amazing and the customers were so nice too. I can't wait to go back, the menu looks so good! And the value for your money is beyond good. The owner Samara was so nice and she over sees everything to make sure everything is perfect, I will be back! ”
“ Sutter’s Mill is back with Sam in the kitchen! Our dinner was great! Everything coming out of the kitchen looked delicious. Food is good quality and cooked the way you like it. My steak and wife’s burger were a treat to eat. We’ll be back for sure. ”
“ Had a great dining experience at Sutters Mill in Suffern last night. The new menu had a great variety of new choices . The Buffalo wings were just like I remembered them from years back. Our entrees were fish tacos, which were delicious.One w cod, other shrimp. Service was excellent. I highly recommend you revisit Sutters and experience the new culinary creations!! ”