Background
Discover

Menu Sutters Mill

Welcome to Sutters Mill, where culinary delights await you at 214 NY59 in Suffern, NY. Known for its relaxed atmosphere and excellent service, this local gem has become a favorite among diners looking for quality comfort food. From the robust flavors of the Buffalo wings to the freshly grilled chicken club, every dish tells a story of culinary passion and creativity.

  • Signature Dishes: Don't miss the mouthwatering salmon paired with sweet potato fries, or the delightful NY fish sandwich that has earned rave reviews.
  • Variety: The menu features a range of options, including fish tacos and hearty burgers, ensuring there's something for everyone.
  • Drinks: Pair your meal with a well-crafted cocktail or select from a variety of wines by the glass.

Experience the charm of Sutters Mill—where every bite is a step closer to culinary magic!

Background

Wine By the Glass

Red

$$7.28

White

$$7.28

Sterling Pinot Noir

$$7.80

Higher End White

$$10.40

Sterling Merlot

$$10.40

-

$$0.00
Background

Tequila

Patron

$$8.32

Casamigos Blanco

$$7.80

Well Tequila

$$6.24

1800

$$8.32

Jose Cuervo

$$7.80

Shot

$$0.00
Background

Wing Night Tuesday

White Russian

$$10.40
Background

Bottle Beer

Coors Light Btl

$$6.24

Rolling Rock

$$6.24

Bud Btl

$$6.24

Bud Light Btl

$$6.24

Corona Light

$$7.28

White Claw

$$6.76

Corona

$$7.28

Heineken

$$7.28

Michelob Light

$$6.24

High Noon

$$7.02
Background

Misc.

Sloe Gin

$$6.24

Chambord

$$6.24

Dr. McGilicuddy's

$$6.24

Amaretto

$$6.24

Peppermint Schnapps

$$6.24

Shot

$$0.00

Applejack

$$6.24

-

$$0.00

Grand Marnier

$$10.40

Disaronno

$$7.80

Peach Snapps

$$6.24
Background

Gin

Well Gin

$$6.24

Tanqueray

$$7.80

Shot

$$0.00

Beefeater

$$7.80

Bombay Sapphire

$$8.32
Background

Starters/Apps

Fried Pickles

$$8.32

Irish Nachos

$$17.68

Sutters Famous Buffalo Wings

$$15.60

Potato Skins

$$12.48

Bangin Brussels

$$10.40

Chicken Potstickers

$$6.24

Chicken Fingers

$$12.48

Mac N Cheese Bites

$$6.24

Vegetable Spring Rolls

$$7.28

-

$$0.00

Nachos Supreme

$$17.68

Fried Fresh Mozzarella

$$10.40

Bavarian Pretzel Sticks

$$9.36

Mozzarella Sticks

$$9.36

Zucchini Sticks

$$7.28

Garlic Bread Parm

$$7.28

Bang Bang Shrimp

$$10.40
Background

Seafood

Shrimp Basket

$$17.68

Seafood Basket

$$18.72

Fish N Chips

$$15.60

Clam Basket

$$15.60

Seared Ahi Tuna Steak

$$26.00

-

$$0.00

Lobster & Shrimp Mac N Cheese

$$0.00

Pan Seared Salmon

$$22.88
Background

Kids Menu

Kid Chicken Fingers

$$12.48

Kid Hot Dog

$$12.48

Kid Cheeseburger

$$12.48

Kid Mac N Cheese

$$12.48

Kid Grilled Cheese

$$12.48

Kid Hamburger

$$12.48

Kid Pasta W/Marinara

$$12.48

Kid Pasta W/Butter

$$12.48

-

$$0.00
Background

Burgers Sliders & Dogs

Sutters Mill Burger

$$13.52

Veggie Burger

$$13.52

Beyond Vegan Burger

$$13.52

Hamburger Sliders

$$13.52

Cheeseburger Sliders

$$14.56

2 Hot Dogs

$$7.28

California Burger

$$16.64

Turkey Burger

$$13.52

Sutters Double Smash Burger

$$17.68

Diet Burger

$$15.60

Sliced Steak Sliders

$$17.68

-

$$0.00

Pulled Pork Sliders

$$16.64
Background

Entrees

Adobo Smoked Churrasco

$$26.00

New York Grill Platter

$$28.08

Shrimp Milano

$$20.80

Penne Ala Vodka

$$15.60

Bowtie Pasta W/Saus&Brocc

$$21.84

Hot Open Turkey

$$17.68

Classic NY Strip Steak

$$26.00

Mac N Cheese

$$11.44

Tortellini Alfredo

$$16.64

8oz Ribeye

$$28.08

Chicken

$$20.80

-

$$0.00

Half Roasted Chicken

$$22.88

Eggplant Parm Towers

$$17.68

Surf & Turf

$$36.40

Tortellini In A Pesto Cream

$$18.72

Penne Pasta

$$17.68

Half Rack BBQ Ribs

$$21.84
Background

Wednesday Margarita

Wednesday Margarita Special

$$6.76
Background

Print Options

Print Credit Order Bill

$$0.00

-

$$0.00

Print Order Bill

$$0.00

Print Cash Order Bill

$$0.00

Print All Guests

$$0.00
Background

Soups & Salads

Tuscany Salad

$$17.68

French Onion Soup

$$8.32

Cobb Salad

$$17.68

Tortellini En Brodo

$$8.32

Crock Of Chili

$$11.44

Wedge Salad

$$14.56

Caesar Salad Large

$$10.40

Soup Of The Day

$$6.24

Garden Salad Small

$$6.24

Garden Salad Large

$$12.48

Crock Of Chili Bowl

$$13.52

Taco Salad

$$13.52

Chef Salad

$$17.68

-

$$0.00

Caesar Salad Small

$$5.20
Background

Sandwich Board

Portobello Mushroom

$$15.60

Nashville Chicken

$$17.68

NY Fish Sandwich

$$16.64

-

$$0.00

Corned Beef Reuben

$$16.64

Grilled Chicken Pesto

$$17.68

Sundried Chicken Hero

$$16.64

Chicken Parm

$$16.64

Sliced Steak Special

$$17.68

Pastrami Reuben

$$16.64

Cubano

$$18.72

Chicken Cordon Bleu

$$16.64

Grilled CHK Ceaser Wrap

$$16.64

Sliced Steak Hero

$$16.64

Meatball Parm

$$16.64

Buffalo Chicken

$$14.56

Pulled Pork Hero

$$18.72

French Dip

$$17.68

Chicken Cutlet Club

$$15.60

Turkey Club

$$14.56

Chicken Claim

$$16.64

Grilled Cheese

$$8.32

BLT

$$9.36
Background

Specialty Cocktails

Vodka Martini

$$13.00

Martini

$$13.00

Bloody Mary

$$10.40

White Russian

$$10.40

Margarita

$$10.40

Cosmopolitan

$$12.48

-

$$0.00
Background

Soft Drinks

Hot Chocolate

$$3.12

Water

$$0.00

Chocolate Milk

$$3.12

Fruit Punch

$$3.12

Club Soda

$$3.12

Diet Pepsi

$$3.12

Sprite

$$3.12

Ice Tea

$$3.12

Hot Tea

$$3.12

Giner Ale

$$3.12

Dr. Pepper

$$3.12

Pepsi

$$3.12

Lemonade

$$3.12

Cranberry Juice

$$3.12

Coffee

$$3.12
Background

CINCO DEMAYO

Chicken

$$10.40
Background

Rum

Malibu

$$7.80

Captin Morgan

$$7.80

Shot

$$0.00

White Rum

$$7.80

Well Rum

$$6.24

Bacardi

$$7.80
Background

Bourbon whiskey Scotch

Seagrams 7

$$7.80

Fireball

$$7.28

Jameson

$$7.02

Woodford Reserve

$$12.48

Southern Comfort

$$6.24

Jack Honey

$$7.80

Jack Fire

$$7.80

Well Bourbon

$$6.24

Jack Daniels

$$7.80

Fleischmann's

$$7.80

Jim Beam

$$7.80

Makers Mark

$$12.48
Background

Tacos

Cheese Quesadilla

$$11.44

Baja Fish Tacos

$$17.68

-

$$0.00

California Taco Platter

$$18.72

Chicken Quesadilla

$$16.64
Background

Fries & Onion Rings

The Old Steak Fries

$$6.24

Garlic Parm Fries

$$10.40

-

$$0.00

Sweet Potato Fries

$$8.32

Hand Cut Fries

$$6.24

Frings

$$8.32

Onion Rings

$$7.28

Waffle Fries

$$7.28

CURLEY FRIES

$$7.28
Background

HOLIDAY MENU EASTER

Easter Mimosa

$$8.32
Background

Vodka

Titos

$$7.28

Shot

$$0.00

Belvedere

$$8.32

Stoli

$$7.28

Kettle One

$$7.54

Well Vodka

$$6.24

Greygoose

$$8.06

Absolut Citron

$$7.28

Stoli Orange

$$7.00

Stoli Raspberry

$$7.28
Background

draft / Tap beers

Captain Lawrence

$$7.28

Bud Light

$$6.24

Sam Adams

$$8.32

Stella

$$8.84

Defiant

$$8.32

Coors Light

$$6.24

Bluemoon

$$7.80

Bud

$$6.24

Guiness

$$8.84
Background

desserts

Toasted Almond Cake

$$8.32

Red Velvet Cake

$$8.32

NY Cheesecake

$$8.32

Chocolate Mousse

$$8.32

Chocolate Lava Cake

$$10.92